The Real Story of Bar-Band Musicians
The Hidden World of Musicians
The vast majority of musicians in America are not the wealthy and famous stars we see on stage. They’re the ones playing in local bars, community centers, and dance halls. Their stories are often untold, but they offer a fascinating glimpse into the true nature of music.
The Balancing Act
For these musicians, the struggle to balance their artistic aspirations with the need to make a living is a constant challenge. The guitarist who earns $50 a night at a local tavern may have a deeper connection to music than the singer who rakes in $100,000 a night at an NBA arena. Their quest to find meaning in their music while also making ends meet is a reflection of our own struggles in life.
Ricki and the Flash: A Missed Opportunity
The new film “Ricki and the Flash” starring Meryl Streep attempts to explore the life of a bar-band musician. However, it fails to capture the true essence of this experience. While Streep gives a convincing performance as a bar-band singer, the film lacks the authenticity and depth that would have made it a truly compelling portrayal of this unique subculture.
Other Notable Films
Despite the shortcomings of “Ricki and the Flash,” there have been a number of other films that have delved into the world of bar-band musicians with greater success.
-
Light of Day (1987): This film depicts a Cleveland bar band led by a single mother and her unreliable brother, both of whom have unresolved family issues.
-
The Commitments (1991): Based on a novel by Roddy Doyle, this film follows a group of young Dubliners who form a horn band to play the music of their American R&B heroes.
-
Inside Llewyn Davis (2013): The Coen Brothers’ film offers a glimpse into the disillusionment and struggles of an early-1960s folk singer buried beneath the shadow of Bob Dylan.
-
Crazy Heart (2009): Jeff Bridges stars as a former country-music star who has fallen so low that he takes gigs in small clubs with unrehearsed bar bands.
-
The Fabulous Baker Boys (1989): Bridges and his brother Beau Bridges play two pop-jazz pianists who perform as a duo in lounges around Seattle. The film explores the tension between artistic and survival goals that all musicians face.
-
Mo’ Better Blues (1990): Spike Lee’s film tells the story of a Brooklyn jazz trumpeter whose talent is thwarted by crooked businessmen.
-
Treme (2010-2013): This HBO series follows the fortunes of multiple Louisiana musicians as they try to survive from gig to gig. The series creator emphasizes that a music career is also a job, and that musicians face the same challenges as anyone else trying to make a living.
The Importance of Context
One of the things that “Ricki and the Flash” fails to explore is the importance of context in shaping music. The music that bar-band musicians play is often influenced by their surroundings and the people they interact with. The film’s portrayal of Ricki and her band as a group of misfits who play mostly cover tunes is a superficial representation of the rich and diverse world of bar-band music.
The Real Mystery of Music
The real mystery of music is not why the wealthy and famous devote their time to it, but why the poor and obscure do. For these musicians, music is not just a career or a hobby. It’s a lifeline, a way to connect with others, and a source of meaning and purpose in their lives.
